Guide
Subsidence costs, insurance claims and who pays to repair
Updated
Before pricing underpinning, establish whether it is really subsidence, and who is paying. If buildings insurance covers it, the bill you care about is the excess, not the per-metre rate.
Signs worth taking seriously
- Diagonal cracks wider than about 3mm, typically near doors and windows, wider at the top than the bottom, these indicative thresholds come from standard surveyor practice, and a structural engineer's opinion beats any checklist.
- Stepped cracking following the mortar joints in brickwork, outside as well as inside.
- Doors and windows sticking in frames that have visibly gone out of square.
- Cracks reopening after redecoration, or appearing after a long dry spell, clay soils shrink in drought, which is why subsidence claims spike in dry years.
- Not every crack is subsidence: new-build settlement and thermal movement are common and mostly cosmetic. Width, pattern and progression are what distinguish them, which is the engineer's job to judge.
How the insurance route runs
- Tell your buildings insurer first, before commissioning your own repairs. Subsidence damage is covered by most UK buildings policies, and unauthorised works can complicate the claim.
- The insurer investigates: a loss adjuster visits, then site investigation (trial pits, drain surveys, tree and soil analysis) and often a period of crack monitoring, which can run for months. Slow is normal here; the insurer must establish the cause before fixing it.
- The cause is treated first: leaking drains repaired, offending trees removed or managed. Many subsidence claims are resolved this way, underpinning is the last resort, not the default.
- If underpinning is specified, the insurer funds the designed scheme and reinstatement; you pay the policy excess, commonly around £1,000 for subsidence, check your own schedule, as excesses vary by policy.
- Keep everything: the engineer's reports, the completion certificate and any guarantees. That file is what future buyers, lenders and insurers will ask for, see does underpinning devalue a house.
When you'd pay yourself
- No buildings insurance, or damage predating the policy and known at inception.
- Underpinning for a project, basement digs and some extensions need underpinning as construction work, which is never an insurance matter. Note that underpinning a shared wall is notifiable under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996.
- Where the claim is declined, for example movement attributed to poor original construction rather than subsidence. Declines can be challenged; an independent engineer's report is the tool.
This is general information, not financial or structural advice: your policy schedule and a structural engineer are the authorities on your own case. Cost figures are typical 2026 quote ranges; the excess figure is described as commonly around £1,000 because policies genuinely vary.